Reviewing weak, reused, and stale passwords
Use Watchtower to find the passwords that will actually get you breached, and fix them in priority order.
Watchtower: the built-in audit
Watchtower continuously checks the items in your vaults and flags the ones that put you at risk. It's the fastest way to find the passwords worth changing, instead of changing them at random.
- Desktop app: click Watchtower in the sidebar.
- Web: sign in at
my.1password.comand open Watchtower. - Phone: the Watchtower tab along the bottom.
You'll see a set of categories. Not all of them are equally urgent — work down the list in this order.
What each category means, and what to do
| Category | What it means | Priority |
|---|---|---|
| Compromised / breached websites | The site appeared in a known data breach after the date you last changed this password. | Change it today, and change it anywhere else you used the same password. |
| Vulnerable passwords | This exact password has appeared in a published breach corpus. Someone, somewhere, has it in a list. | Change immediately. Treat the account as already known to attackers. |
| Reused passwords | The same password protects more than one item. | High. Fix the most valuable account in each reuse group first. |
| Weak passwords | Short, dictionary-based, or predictable enough to be guessed by machine. | High for anything with money, customer data, or admin rights behind it. |
| Inactive two-factor authentication | The site supports 2FA and you haven't turned it on. | Very high value for the effort — see Storing two-factor (2FA) codes. |
| Unsecured websites | The saved address is http://, so credentials travel unencrypted. |
Update the item to https://. If the site has no HTTPS at all, tell the helpdesk. |
| Expiring items | Cards, licences, or documents with an expiry date approaching. | Housekeeping — clear it during your monthly review. |
How to run a review that actually finishes
A list of 200 flagged items is demoralising, and demoralising reviews get abandoned. Do it in passes instead.
- Pass one — the crown jewels (30 minutes). Ignore the list at first. Write down the accounts that would hurt most if lost: email, banking, payroll, the domain registrar, your Microsoft 365 or Google tenant, remote access, and anything holding customer data. Give each a fresh generated password and turn on 2FA. Most of your risk lives in these ten accounts.
- Pass two — compromised and vulnerable. Work Watchtower's breach lists top to bottom. These are known-bad, not theoretical.
- Pass three — reuse. Open each reuse group and fix the highest-value account in it first. Every one you fix shrinks the blast radius of the next breach.
- Pass four — weak passwords, ten a week. Put a recurring 20-minute slot in your calendar. Ten a week clears several hundred in a year, and it never feels like a project.
Open the item → Open and fill → find the site's change-password page → generate a new password → save → accept 1Password's Update prompt. The slowest part is finding the site's settings page.
Stale items: the other half of the job
Watchtower flags weak passwords, but it can't tell you an account shouldn't exist any more. That part is human judgement. Once a quarter, skim your vaults for:
- Accounts belonging to people who have left. These should be disabled at the vendor, not just deleted from the vault.
- Services nobody uses. A dormant account is still an account someone can break into — and often still a bill.
- Duplicate items for the same account, usually with different passwords. Work out which one is current, verify it by signing in, then archive the rest.
- Items with no website address, which never autofill and so never get updated.
- Shared logins that should be individual accounts. If four people use one login to a vendor portal, ask the vendor for named accounts. Shared accounts destroy accountability and make offboarding painful.
- Passwords last changed years ago on important systems — the item's history shows the date it was last updated.
Forcing everyone to change every password every 60 days is discredited practice — it produces
Summer2026! then Autumn2026!. Modern guidance, including NIST's, is to
change a password when there's a reason to: a breach, a suspicion, a departure, a shared account
someone no longer should have. Strong, unique, and 2FA-protected beats frequently rotated.
A quarterly rhythm worth keeping
- Watchtower shows zero compromised and zero vulnerable items
- No reused passwords on anything holding money, customer data, or admin rights
- 2FA is on for email, finance, remote access, and every administrator account
- Every work login that others may need lives in a shared vault, not a private one
- Leavers' accounts are disabled at the vendor and their items archived
- No duplicate items for the same account
Drill 03 — Ye Olde Pigeon Post hands you an inherited nine-character password and makes you replace it — including the part people get wrong, choosing Update instead of Save as new.
Stuck, or something looks different?
1Password's apps change their wording from time to time, and your company may have vaults set up differently from the examples here. If a step doesn't match what you see, don't guess and don't work around it — call the Activity3 helpdesk at +1 (208) 944-9200 or email info@activity3.com and we'll walk through it with you.